📚 Leonardo da Vinci by Walter Isaacson

Cover image sourced from Goodreads. All rights reserved by the copyright holders. Used for educational/review purposes under fair use guidelines.

Key Takeaways Table

Aspect	Details
Core Thesis	Leonardo da Vinci's genius stemmed from his ability to connect art and science, his relentless curiosity, and his perfectionism. These scientific inquiries directly nourished his artistic achievements.
Structure	Chronological biography with thematic chapters, following Leonardo's life from childhood through his periods in Florence, Milan, Rome, and France, while examining his notebooks, scientific studies, and major artistic works.
Strengths	Comprehensive research using Leonardo's 7,200 notebook pages, accessible narrative style, beautiful illustrations, insightful analysis of the art-science connection, practical lessons on creativity and innovation.
Weaknesses	Occasional overly enthusiastic tone, limited personal revelations due to historical constraints, some art criticism feels forced, "TED-ism" in the concluding lessons, uneven depth across different subjects.
Target Audience	General readers interested in Renaissance history, art enthusiasts, scientists curious about historical connections, creativity seekers, biography lovers, students of innovation.
Criticisms	Breathless praise reminiscent of Apple product reviews, art criticism that sometimes lacks scholarly depth, overcompensation for limited personal sources, formulaic "lessons from Leonardo" conclusion.

Introduction

Leonardo da Vinci (2017) by Walter Isaacson represents the culmination of the acclaimed biographer's exploration of genius, following his bestselling works on Steve Jobs, Albert Einstein, and Benjamin Franklin. A former journalist, CNN executive, and president of the Aspen Institute, Isaacson brings his signature accessible style to the quintessential Renaissance man, creating what Bill Gates calls "the first book that satisfactorily covered all the different facets of his life and work." With degrees from Harvard and Oxford (as a Rhodes Scholar), Isaacson has established himself as the premier biographer of innovative thinkers, making complex subjects approachable for general readers.

Published by Simon & Schuster as a 624-page illustrated hardcover, Leonardo da Vinci became a #1 New York Times bestseller and captured widespread public attention, coinciding remarkably with the record-breaking $450 million sale of Leonardo's Salvator Mundi painting. Isaacson, who owns Leonardo's Codex Leicester notebook, approaches his subject with both scholarly rigor and personal fascination, declaring that Leonardo "was history's most creative genius" whose secrets can teach us about innovation and creativity.

In an era of increasing specialization and technological disruption, Isaacson's exploration of history's ultimate polymath offers timely insights into the nature of creativity and innovation. By examining how Leonardo connected art and science, observation and imagination, Isaacson provides a framework for understanding genius that remains relevant today. Let's explore his comprehensive biography, evaluate its compelling insights and occasional shortcomings, and assess its contribution to our understanding of creativity and interdisciplinary thinking.

Summary

Isaacson structures his biography as both a chronological narrative and thematic exploration, revealing how Leonardo's diverse interests and scientific inquiries directly informed his artistic masterpieces.

Part I: Formation and Early Years

The book begins with Leonardo's unconventional upbringing and artistic development:

Illegitimate Birth: Leonardo's status as an illegitimate son of a notary and peasant girl freed him from formal education, allowing him to become a "disciple of experience" rather than book learning.
Verrocchio's Workshop: Leonardo's apprenticeship under Andrea del Verrocchio in Florence provided his foundation in art and exposed him to diverse crafts from painting to sculpture to engineering.
Early Independence: Isaacson traces Leonardo's development from apprentice to independent artist, highlighting his first masterpieces like The Annunciation and Ginevra de' Benci.

Deep Dive: Isaacson analyzes how Leonardo's lack of formal education became an advantage, allowing him to approach knowledge with fresh curiosity rather than accepting received wisdom. As Leonardo wrote: "He who can go to the fountain does not go to the water-jar."

Part II: Milanese Maturity

This section covers Leonardo's most productive period in Milan, where he balanced artistic commissions with scientific studies:

Sforca Court: Leonardo's service to Ludovico Sforca in Milan provided stability and resources for his diverse projects, from The Last Supper to architectural designs.
Notebook Development: Isaacson examines how Leonardo's notebooks evolved from simple sketches to comprehensive scientific investigations, covering anatomy, optics, geology, and engineering.
Vitruvian Man: The creation of this iconic drawing symbolizes Leonardo's fusion of art and science, mathematical precision and human observation.

Case Study: Isaacson details Leonardo's obsessive study of human anatomy, including his dissection of corpses to understand muscle structure, which directly informed his ability to paint the Mona Lisa's enigmatic smile.

Part III: Scientific Pursuits

The third section explores Leonardo's scientific investigations and their connection to his art:

Anatomical Studies: Leonardo's unprecedented dissections and anatomical drawings contributed to medical knowledge, including the first description of arteriosclerosis.
Engineering Innovations: Isaacson examines Leonardo's designs for flying machines, weapons, and hydraulic systems, showing how his artistic skills enhanced his engineering vision.
Mathematical Explorations: Leonardo's study of proportion, perspective, and geometry bridged artistic composition and mathematical precision.

Key Insight: Isaacson demonstrates how Leonardo's scientific inquiries weren't distractions from his art but essential to it. The understanding of light, optics, and human anatomy directly enabled his artistic breakthroughs.

Part IV: Later Years and Legacy

The final section covers Leonardo's travels and final works:

Roman Period: Leonardo's time in Rome working for the Medici, marked by competition with Michelangelo and continued scientific investigations.
French Years: Leonardo's final years in France under the patronage of King Francis I, where he continued working on the Mona Lisa until his death.
Enduring Influence: Isaacson traces Leonardo's impact on art, science, and our understanding of creativity itself.

Key Themes

Art-Science Connection: Leonardo's greatest insight was that art and science were complementary rather than separate disciplines.
Curiosity as Engine: Leonardo's relentless curiosity drove both his artistic and scientific achievements.
Perfectionism as Double-Edged Sword: His perfectionism led to masterpieces but also many unfinished works.
Observation Over Authority: Leonardo trusted direct experience over received knowledge, making him a pioneer of empirical thinking.
Interdisciplinary Genius: Leonardo's ability to connect disparate fields enabled insights that specialists might miss.
Imperfection as Humanizing: Leonardo's failures and unfinished works make his achievements more relatable and instructive.
Timeless Relevance: Leonardo's approach to creativity and innovation remains applicable in our modern age of specialization.

Analysis

Strengths

Comprehensive Research: Isaacson's mastery of Leonardo's 7,200 notebook pages provides unprecedented insight into his thought processes. As Bill Gates noted, Isaacson "did a great job pulling it all together" in a way that no previous Leonardo biography had achieved [Gates Notes]. This thorough research allows readers to understand Leonardo's thinking as it evolved across decades.
Accessible Narrative Style: Isaacson brings complex artistic and scientific concepts to life for general readers. The Washington Post praised his "fundamentally journalistic" approach that is "graceful" but "never needlessly ornate" while demonstrating that "he knows his stuff" [Washington Post]. This accessibility makes Leonardo's genius understandable to readers without specialized knowledge.
Beautiful Illustrations: The book features full-color reproductions of Leonardo's paintings, drawings, and notebook pages, allowing readers to see what Isaacson describes. Amazon customers specifically praise the "full-color pictures of every classic work by Leonardo" that make it "beautifully illustrated" [Amazon]. This visual richness enhances understanding of Leonardo's artistic techniques.
Insightful Art-Science Analysis: Isaacson's central thesis about the connection between Leonardo's artistic and scientific work is compelling and well-supported. The Guardian review praised how Isaacson shows that "only through the work he put into dissecting corpses and studying muscles was he capable of painting the Mona Lisa's smile". This analysis provides a fresh framework for understanding Leonardo's genius.
Practical Lessons on Creativity: The book concludes with applicable insights about creativity and innovation that readers can apply in their own lives. Isaacson extracts principles like "be curious, relentlessly curious" and "think visually" that make Leonardo's approach relevant to modern readers [Wikipedia]. This practical dimension elevates the book beyond pure biography to become a guide to creative thinking.

Weaknesses

Overly Enthusiastic Tone: Isaacson's admiration for Leonardo sometimes leads to breathless praise that lacks critical distance. The New York Times noted that Isaacson "hails many of Leonardo's creations in the same breathless tone with which a teenager might greet a new Apple product," with words like "brilliant," "wondrous," and "ingenious" appearing frequently. This enthusiasm can undermine critical analysis.
Limited Personal Revelations: Due to the historical record, Isaacson has limited personal material about Leonardo's inner life. As the NYT review noted, Leonardo's notebooks "lack...'intimate personal revelations'" which forces Isaacson to "overcompensate with copious analyses of Leonardo's works". This focus on analysis over personality can make Leonardo feel somewhat distant as a biographical subject.
Forced Art Criticism: Some critics feel Isaacson is not entirely comfortable in the role of art critic. The NYT suggested that "the role of art critic suits him" poorly, noting that he sometimes adopts "the oracular tone of a museum docent" with lines like "the landscape of her soul and of nature's soul are intertwined" about the Mona Lisa. This art criticism can feel less assured than his biographical writing.
Formulaic "Lessons" Conclusion: The book's final section with lessons from Leonardo has been criticized as "TED-ism", oversimplified, self-help style takeaways. The NYT described this as a form of "TED-ism" that reduces complex genius to bullet points. While practical, this approach can feel formulaic compared to the nuanced biography that precedes it.

Critical Reception

Leonardo da Vinci received predominantly positive reviews, reflecting its success in making Leonardo accessible to general readers. The Guardian described it as "sumptuous, elegantly written and diligently produced". Bill Gates, who owns Leonardo's Codex Leicester, praised it as covering "all the different facets of his life and work" in a way no previous book had. The book became a #1 New York Times bestseller, indicating widespread popular appeal.

Professional reviews were more mixed. The Washington Post praised Isaacson's "fundamententially journalistic" approach and deep knowledge, concluding that while "graceful," his writing is "never needlessly ornate". However, the New York Times was more critical, suggesting Isaacson seemed uncomfortable as an art critic and noting his "breathless tone" in praising Leonardo's work. The Wall Street Journal compared it unfavorably to Mike Lankford's Becoming Leonardo, feeling Isaacson's book "feels cobbled together, as if written on deadline".

Reader response on Goodreads has been overwhelmingly positive, with the book maintaining a 4+ star rating from over 120,000 ratings. Readers consistently praise its accessibility, fascinating content, and beautiful illustrations. Many echo Bill Gates' sentiment that it helps readers "see him as a complete human being and understand just how special he was".

Academic reception has been more reserved, with art historians appreciating the book's accessibility but noting its limitations in scholarly depth. The book's strength lies in its ability to spark interest in Leonardo rather than provide definitive scholarly analysis.

Comparison to Other Works

vs. Leonardo: The Artist and the Man (Serge Bramly): Bramly's work is more focused on artistic analysis and scholarly depth; Isaacson's is more accessible and broader in scope, covering science and engineering as well as art. Bramly is better for art specialists; Isaacson is better for general readers.
vs. Becoming Leonardo (Mike Lankford): Lankford's book is more interpretive and psychological; Isaacson's is more factual and comprehensive. The WSJ suggested Lankford "seems to have taken all the time he needed" while Isaacson's feels more rushed.
vs. Leonardo da Vinci: Flights of the Mind (Charles Nicholl): Nicholl's work is more literary and biographically focused; Isaacson's is more analytical and thematically structured. Nicholl is better for literary biography fans; Isaacson is better for those interested in creativity and innovation.
vs. The Notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci (various editors): Primary source collections offer direct access to Leonardo's thinking; Isaacson provides context and analysis that makes the notebooks understandable to modern readers. The notebooks are essential for specialists; Isaacson is essential for general understanding.

Conclusion

Leonardo da Vinci represents a significant achievement in popular biography, making history's ultimate polymath accessible to contemporary readers. Isaacson's comprehensive exploration of Leonardo's life, work, and thought processes offers valuable insights into the nature of creativity and innovation. While its strengths (comprehensive research, accessible narrative style, beautiful illustrations, insightful art-science analysis, and practical lessons on creativity) make it essential reading for anyone interested in understanding genius, its limitations (overly enthusiastic tone, limited personal revelations, forced art criticism, and formulaic conclusion) remind us that it serves best as an introduction rather than definitive scholarly work.

For general readers, art enthusiasts, and anyone interested in creativity and innovation, this book is highly recommended. As Isaacson demonstrates, Leonardo's greatest lesson is the power of connecting different disciplines and maintaining relentless curiosity about the world. By examining how Leonardo bridged art and science, observation and imagination, Isaacson provides a framework for understanding creativity that remains remarkably relevant in our age of specialization.

However, readers should supplement Isaacson's work with more specialized studies: Leonardo: The Artist and the Man (Serge Bramly) for deeper artistic analysis, The Notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci for direct access to his thinking, and Leonardo da Vinci: The Marvellous Works of Nature and Man (Martin Kemp) for scholarly depth on his scientific work. Isaacson's work is engaging but not exhaustive.

In an era where artificial intelligence and technological disruption raise questions about human creativity, Leonardo da Vinci provides a powerful reminder of the enduring value of interdisciplinary thinking and curiosity. As one reviewer summarized, Isaacson helps readers "see him as a complete human being and understand just how special he was" [Gates Notes]. For those seeking to understand the nature of genius and how to cultivate creativity in their own lives, this beautifully illustrated and thoughtfully crafted biography remains essential reading.

Key Actionable Insights:

Embrace Curiosity: Follow Leonardo's example of relentless curiosity about how things work, from natural phenomena to human anatomy.
Connect Disciplines: Look for connections between different fields of knowledge like art and science, observation and imagination.
Value Experience Over Authority: Trust direct observation and experience over received wisdom or established authorities.
Embrace Imperfection: Understand that perfectionism can be both a strength and weakness; sometimes unfinished work teaches valuable lessons.
Think Visually: Use drawing and visual thinking as tools for understanding complex problems and ideas.
Maintain Childlike Wonder: Keep the sense of wonder and curiosity that drives discovery and innovation.
Balance Breadth and Depth: While specialization has value, maintaining broad interests can lead to unique insights and connections.

Leonardo da Vinci is a mirror reflecting the potential of human creativity and curiosity. In Isaacson's words, Leonardo teaches us that "genius hits a target no one else can see" by connecting disparate fields and maintaining relentless curiosity about the world. For those seeking to understand the nature of innovation and creativity in our modern age, this comprehensive and accessible biography opens doorways to understanding one of history's most fascinating minds.

Crepi il lupo! 🐺