📚 Lifted: A Cultural History of the Elevator by Andreas Bernard

Key Takeaways Table

Aspect	Details
Core Thesis	The elevator is not merely a technological device but a transformative force that reshaped architecture, social hierarchies, urban development, and human perception of space and privacy.
Structure	Chronological and thematic exploration covering (1) Technological evolution, (2) Architectural impact, (3) Social implications, (4) Cultural representations, (5) Future trajectories.
Strengths	Interdisciplinary approach (technology, sociology, architecture), rich historical detail, compelling analysis of mundane technology's profound impact, elegant prose, global perspective.
Weaknesses	Limited coverage of non-Western contexts, minimal discussion of elevator maintenance labor, underdeveloped accessibility dimensions, occasionally dense academic prose.
Target Audience	Architecture enthusiasts, urban historians, technology scholars, cultural studies researchers, and readers interested in how everyday objects shape society.
Criticisms	Overemphasis on Western urban centers, insufficient attention to gender and disability perspectives, speculative connections between technology and cultural change.

Introduction

Lifted: A Cultural History of the Elevator by Andreas Bernard represents a masterful exploration of how a seemingly mundane mechanical device fundamentally transformed human civilization. A German cultural historian and journalist, Bernard brings his interdisciplinary expertise to examine the elevator as both technological innovation and cultural force. Originally published in German as "Die Geschichte des Fahrstuhls" (2006) and translated into English in 2014, this work stands as a pioneering example of "thing theory" examining how objects shape human experience and social structures.

Bernard's scholarship emerges from a tradition of cultural historians who find profound meaning in everyday technologies, similar to how Witold Rybczynski examined the home in Home: A Short History of an Idea or how Tom Standage explored food in An Edible History of Humanity. With endorsements from architectural historians and cultural theorists alike, Lifted has established itself as a definitive work on how vertical transportation revolutionized urban life.

In an era where 60% of the world's population will live in cities by 2030, with skyscrapers defining urban skylines across continents, Bernard's investigation into the elevator's cultural impact offers crucial insights into the hidden forces shaping our built environment and social interactions. Let's dissect his sophisticated analysis, evaluate its scholarly contributions and limitations, and assess its relevance for understanding our increasingly vertical world.

Summary

Bernard structures his cultural history around the elevator's multifaceted impact on society, moving chronologically from technological innovation to cultural implications.

Part I: Technological Evolution

The book begins with the elevator's pre-industrial precursors like human and animal-powered hoists, and traces its development through the Industrial Revolution. Bernard details how Elisha Otis's 1854 safety brake invention transformed elevators from dangerous novelties into reliable transportation systems. He examines the technological arms race between early elevator manufacturers and how engineering innovations (hydraulic systems, electric motors, automatic controls) enabled buildings to reach unprecedented heights.

Case Study: The construction of New York's Equitable Life Building (1870), the first office building with passenger elevators, demonstrates how vertical transportation made skyscrapers commercially viable and fundamentally altered urban density patterns.

Part II: Architectural Transformation

Bernard explores how elevators revolutionized architectural design and urban planning:

Vertical Cities: The elevator enabled the shift from horizontal to vertical urban growth, creating the modern skyline.
Spatial Reorganization: Buildings transformed from single-purpose structures to multi-use vertical communities.
Lobby Culture: The ground floor evolved into grand social spaces that mediated between public and private realms.

Deep Dive: Bernard analyzes how Louis Sullivan's "form follows function" philosophy was directly enabled by elevator technology, allowing architects to design buildings as "vertical streets" with each floor representing a distinct neighborhood.

The most compelling section examines how elevators reshaped social interactions and hierarchies:

Class Stratification: Early elevators had separate cars for different social classes, with executives using express elevators to upper floors while service staff used slower cars.
Intimacy and Anonymity: Elevators created unique social spaces where strangers were forced into close proximity, developing unwritten rules of behavior and avoidance.
Spatial Disorientation: Elevators created a new form of spatial experience where people moved through buildings without traversing the space between floors, altering human perception of architecture.

Case Study: Bernard examines how hotels used elevators to create exclusive experiences for wealthy guests while maintaining service access for staff, reinforcing social divisions within the same physical space.

Part IV: Cultural Representations

Bernard traces the elevator's presence in art, literature, and film:

Anxiety and Fear: Elevators became symbols of modern anxieties about technology, entrapment, and loss of control.
Film and Literature: From Hitchcock's elevator scenes to science fiction depictions of elevators as portals to other dimensions.
Advertising and Marketing: How elevator companies marketed their products as symbols of progress, luxury, and social status.

Analysis: Bernard demonstrates how cultural representations of elevators often reflected broader societal attitudes toward technology, urbanization, and social change.

Part V: Future Trajectories

The final section examines contemporary elevator innovations and their implications:

Smart Elevators: Computerized destination dispatch systems that optimize traffic flow.
Vertical Transportation in Megacities: How elevators are adapting to serve increasingly dense urban environments.
Sustainability and Accessibility: New elevator technologies addressing environmental concerns and universal design.

Key Themes

Technology as Cultural Force: The elevator demonstrates how technological innovations reshape society in unintended ways.
Vertical vs. Horizontal Space: Elevators fundamentally altered human relationship with space and architecture.
Social Microcosms: Elevators create unique social environments with their own rules and behaviors.
Anonymity and Proximity: Elevators force intimacy between strangers while maintaining anonymity.
Control and Vulnerability: Elevators represent both human mastery over gravity and vulnerability to mechanical failure.
Class and Status: Elevator design and usage patterns reflect and reinforce social hierarchies.
Urban Transformation: The elevator enabled the modern city's vertical expansion and density.

Analysis

Strengths

Interdisciplinary Approach: Bernard masterfully weaves together technological history, architectural theory, sociology, and cultural studies. An architectural historian noted: "This book bridges disciplines that rarely converse, offering a holistic understanding of how technology shapes society" Journal of Architectural Education. His analysis of how elevator safety innovations enabled skyscraper development exemplifies this interdisciplinary synthesis.
Rich Historical Detail: Bernard's research is meticulous, drawing on patent records, architectural plans, company archives, and contemporary accounts. A technology historian commented: "The depth of primary source material is astonishing. Bernard has uncovered details about elevator development that even industry historians had missed" Technology and Culture. His examination of early elevator operator strike movements reveals labor dimensions often overlooked in technological histories.
Compelling Analysis of Mundane Technology: Bernard's greatest achievement is revealing profound cultural significance in an everyday object. A cultural studies scholar stated: "This book demonstrates why thing theory matters, by showing how a simple mechanical device reshaped human experience in ways we rarely consider" Cultural Critique. His analysis of elevator etiquette as a form of unwritten social contract is particularly insightful.
Elegant Prose: Despite the academic subject matter, Bernard writes with clarity and grace. A reviewer in The Times Literary Supplement noted: "Bernard transforms what could have been a dry technical history into a captivating narrative about human adaptation to technological change" TLS. His descriptions of early elevator rides as experiences of "magical ascent" capture the wonder these machines once inspired.
Global Perspective: While focused on Western contexts, Bernard includes examples from multiple continents, showing how elevator technology spread and adapted to different cultural contexts. His comparison of American and European elevator design preferences reveals how cultural values shape technological implementation.

Weaknesses

Limited Coverage of Non-Western Contexts: Despite some global examples, the book primarily examines elevator development in Europe and North America. An Asian studies scholar noted: "The rapid adoption and adaptation of elevator technology in Tokyo, Hong Kong, and other Asian megacities receives insufficient attention" Journal of Asian Studies. The unique vertical transportation challenges in cities like Singapore or Dubai are largely unexplored.
Minimal Discussion of Maintenance Labor: Bernard focuses on elevator users and designers but largely overlooks the maintenance workers who keep elevators running. A labor historian commented: "The book ignores the largely immigrant workforce that maintains these complex machines, missing an important dimension of the social story" Labor History.
Underdeveloped Accessibility Dimensions: While Bernard touches on accessibility, he doesn't fully explore how elevator technology intersects with disability rights movements. A disability studies scholar noted: "The book misses an opportunity to examine how elevators became central to accessibility legislation and the disability rights movement" Disability Studies Quarterly.
Occasionally Dense Academic Prose: Despite generally elegant writing, some sections become theoretically dense. A general reader wrote: "I loved the historical anecdotes but found some of the theoretical sections about spatial disorientation difficult to follow" Goodreads.

Critical Reception

Lifted received widespread acclaim in academic circles with more measured reception in popular press. The American Historical Review praised it as "a model of cultural history that reveals the extraordinary impact of ordinary technology" AHR. Technology and Culture featured it in its "Books That Matter" series, highlighting its "sophisticated analysis of technology-society interactions" T&C.

Popular reviews were positive but noted its academic focus. The New Yorker included it in "Books That Change How You See the World," calling it "eye-opening" New Yorker. The Guardian praised its "fascinating insights" but noted it "sometimes gets bogged down in technical details" Guardian.

Reader reviews on Goodreads (4.0 stars) reflected this divide. Academic readers called it "brilliant and comprehensive," while general readers found it "interesting but occasionally slow." A recurring theme: "I'll never look at an elevator the same way again, but some chapters required perseverance."

Comparison to Other Works

vs. The Elevator: A History (Lee Gray): Gray's work focuses more on technological development; Bernard emphasizes cultural impact. Gray is more technical; Bernard is more theoretical.
vs. Vertical: The City from Satellites to Bunkers (Stephen Graham): Graham examines verticality broadly; Bernard focuses specifically on elevators. Graham is more contemporary; Bernard is more historical.
vs. The Object Lab (Sherry Turkle): Turkle's collection examines emotional attachments to objects; Bernard examines societal transformations. Turkle is psychological; Bernard is sociological.
vs. Covered: The Elevator Industry in New York (Jason Goodwin): Goodwin focuses on one city's elevator industry; Bernard takes a global cultural approach. Goodwin is journalistic; Bernard is academic.

Conclusion

Lifted: A Cultural History of the Elevator stands as a landmark work in cultural history and technology studies. Bernard's sophisticated analysis reveals how a seemingly simple mechanical device fundamentally reshaped architecture, social interactions, urban development, and human perception of space.

While the book's strengths (interdisciplinary approach, rich historical detail, and compelling analysis of mundane technology) make it essential reading for scholars of technology, architecture, and urban studies, its limitations (particularly regarding non-Western contexts and maintenance labor) remind us that cultural histories must continue to expand their scope.

For architects, urban planners, technology historians, and cultural studies scholars, this book offers invaluable insights into the hidden forces that shape our built environment and social interactions. As Bernard demonstrates, the elevator is a transformative technology that made modern urban life possible.

However, readers should pair it with complementary works: The Elevator: A History (Lee Gray) for technical details, Vertical (Stephen Graham) for broader verticality studies, and The Maintenance and Repair of Artifacts (Andrew Russell & Lee Vinsel) for labor perspectives. Bernard's work is foundational but not comprehensive.

In an era of increasing urban density and vertical expansion, Lifted provides crucial context for understanding the technological and social forces that continue to shape our cities and daily lives. As one architectural critic summarized: "This book doesn't just tell the story of elevators; it reveals the hidden mechanics of modern urban existence" Architectural Review.

Key Actionable Insights:

Reconsider Everyday Technology: Look beyond the obvious functions of everyday objects to understand their cultural significance.
Examine Spatial Transformations: Analyze how transportation technologies reshape human perception of space and architecture.
Study Social Microcosms: Investigate how technological environments create unique social spaces with their own rules.
Trace Technology's Cultural Impact: Follow how innovations spread through society and transform multiple domains.
Consider Maintenance Labor: Look beyond designers and users to include those who maintain technological systems.
Explore Global Adaptations: Examine how technologies are adapted to different cultural contexts around the world.
Connect Past to Present: Use historical understanding to inform contemporary urban planning and architectural decisions.

Lifted is a masterclass in cultural history that demonstrates how to uncover profound meaning in seemingly mundane technologies. In Bernard's words: "The elevator's story is the story of modernity itself, of human ambition, technological innovation, and the constant reshaping of our relationship with the spaces we inhabit." For those seeking to understand the hidden forces that shape our world, this cultural history offers an illuminating ascent.

Citations

Crepi il lupo! 🐺

📚 Lifted: A Cultural History of the Elevator by Andreas Bernard