📚 Make It Stick by Peter C. Brown, Henry L. Roediger III, & Mark A. McDaniel

Cover image sourced from Goodreads. All rights reserved by the copyright holders. Used for educational/review purposes under fair use guidelines.

Key Takeaways

Aspect	Details
Core Thesis	Effective, long-term learning is not achieved through passive, intuitive techniques like re-reading, but through active, effortful, and counter-intuitive strategies rooted in cognitive science, such as retrieval practice, spacing, and interleaving.
Structure	Narrative-driven exploration of cognitive science principles: (1) Debunking common learning myths, (2) Explaining the power of retrieval practice, (3) The benefits of spaced and interleaved practice, (4) The importance of "desirable difficulties," (5) Avoiding illusions of knowing, (6) Elaboration and other effective strategies, (7) Applying these principles for lifelong learning.
Strengths	Firmly grounded in empirical cognitive psychology research, provides highly practical and evidence-based strategies, uses compelling real-world stories and analogies, directly challenges and corrects popular but ineffective study habits, accessible to a general audience without a science background.
Weaknesses	The narrative structure can sometimes feel repetitive, some readers may prefer a more direct "how-to" guide rather than a blend of stories and science, lacks a prescriptive, step-by-step system for implementation.
Target Audience	Students (high school, university), teachers and educators, corporate trainers, professionals, and anyone interested in improving their ability to learn and remember new information effectively.
Criticisms	Some readers find the core advice could be summarized more concisely, the strategies require more discipline and effort than conventional methods, the book focuses more on the "what" and "why" than the granular "how" of integrating these techniques into a daily routine.

Introduction

Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning by Peter C. Brown, Henry L. Roediger III, and Mark A. McDaniel represents a powerful challenge to our most common and cherished learning habits. Drawing on decades of rigorous research in cognitive psychology, the authors (a storyteller and two leading cognitive scientists) dismantle popular but ineffective study methods and replace them with a set of potent, evidence-backed strategies. The book has been praised as "a revelation for students and teachers alike" and "the definitive guide to learning how to learn based on solid science."

This book is not a collection of folksy wisdom or trendy "brain hacks"; it's a synthesis of foundational research on memory and cognition, translated into practical advice. The authors combine findings from laboratory studies and real-world examples, from surgeons learning new procedures to pilots training in flight simulators, to build an unshakeable case for a new approach to learning. Its central message is revolutionary for many: learning that feels easy is often forgotten, while learning that requires mental effort is what truly lasts.

In a world demanding constant up-skilling and adaptation, understanding the principles of durable knowledge is more critical than ever. Let's examine the core strategies advocated by the authors, evaluate the science behind them, and consider how this framework can transform our approach to education and self-improvement.

Summary

Brown, Roediger, and McDaniel structure their argument around a simple but profound insight: our intuition about what works for learning is often wrong. The book systematically replaces these flawed intuitions with scientifically validated, though often more demanding, techniques.

Part I: The Power of Retrieval

This section introduces the single most important concept in the book: learning is an active process of retrieving information from memory.

To Learn, Retrieve: The act of recalling information strengthens memory pathways and makes knowledge more durable and flexible. This is the opposite of passively reviewing material.
Testing as a Study Tool: Low-stakes quizzing and self-testing are not just tools for assessment; they are powerful learning activities that interrupt the process of forgetting.

Deep Dive: The authors introduce the concept of "desirable difficulties." These are obstacles that make learning feel harder and slower in the short term but lead to much stronger, longer-lasting retention. Effortful retrieval is a prime example of a desirable difficulty.

Part II: Spacing, Interleaving, and Variation

The book then explores how to structure practice for maximum long-term benefit.

Spaced Repetition: Spacing out study sessions on a topic over time is far more effective than cramming. Allowing some time for forgetting makes the subsequent retrieval effort more potent.
Interleaving: Mixing practice of different but related skills or concepts in a single session, rather than blocking practice (mastering one thing before moving to the next), leads to better discrimination and more versatile knowledge.
Varied Practice: Varying the conditions and types of practice helps learners develop a more flexible understanding that can be applied in novel situations.

Case Study: The authors use the example of learning to hit different baseball pitches. A batter who practices hitting fastballs, curveballs, and sliders in a random (interleaved) order develops the crucial skill of identifying the pitch type and selecting the right response, a skill that blocked practice (hitting 20 fastballs, then 20 curveballs) fails to build.

Part III: Avoiding Illusions of Knowledge

A key part of the authors' argument is teaching readers to recognize when they are not actually learning.

The Illusion of Fluency: Mistaking the ease and familiarity of re-reading or highlighting material for genuine mastery. This is the most common trap learners fall into.
Embrace Elaboration and Generation: True learning involves connecting new information to what you already know (elaboration) and trying to answer a question or solve a problem before being shown the solution (generation). Both are effortful processes that create robust memories.

Framework: The authors present the "elaboration framework" - a mental model where you actively work to find new layers of meaning in new material, relate it to your existing knowledge, and express it in your own words. This process makes knowledge uniquely your own and far more memorable.

Key Themes

Effortful Learning is Deep Learning: Strategies that require mental exertion, like retrieval and generation, are far more effective than passive ones.
Embrace Difficulties: The most effective learning feels hard. Obstacles that force you to work are not signs of failure but catalysts for strong memory formation.
Test Yourself, Don't Just Review: Quizzing is a primary study tool, not just a measurement tool.
Distrust Fluency: The feeling of mastery gained from re-reading is often an illusion. True mastery is demonstrated by the ability to recall and apply knowledge.
Structure Practice Intelligently: Use spacing and interleaving to build durable, flexible knowledge instead of cramming or blocking practice.
Lifelong Learning Mindset: The principles in the book apply not just to school but to acquiring any skill or knowledge throughout life.

Comparison to Other Works

vs. The Study Skills Handbook (Stella Cottrell): Cottrell offers a holistic, practical guide to academic life, including time management and wellbeing. Make It Stick focuses exclusively on the cognitive science of how to make learning durable, providing the "why" behind effective study techniques.
vs. Mindset (Carol S. Dweck): Dweck focuses on the psychological belief that one's abilities can be developed. Make It Stick provides the specific, evidence-based strategies for how to develop those abilities. The two books are highly complementary.
vs. Ultralearning (Scott H. Young): Young outlines an aggressive, project-based strategy for rapidly acquiring hard skills. Make It Stick provides the underlying cognitive principles (like retrieval and spacing) that make many of Young's tactics effective.
vs. A Mind for Numbers (Barbara Oakley): Oakley provides practical tips for math and science students, including concepts like chunking and battling procrastination. Make It Stick covers the same foundational cognitive science but applies it more broadly across all domains of learning.

Key Actionable Insights

Practice Retrieval Constantly: After reading a chapter or attending a lecture, put the material away and write down or say aloud everything you can remember. Use flashcards, but focus on recalling the answer before turning the card over.
Space Out Your Practice: Instead of cramming for a test, plan several shorter study sessions on the same topic spread out over days or weeks.
Interleave Your Subjects: When studying, mix up different topics. If you're studying math, do problems from several different chapters in one session rather than just one.
Elaborate on New Ideas: When you learn something new, ask yourself how it relates to things you already know. Try to explain it to someone else in your own words.
Generate Solutions: Before looking at the answer to a problem, try to solve it on your own, even if you're not sure you can. The struggle itself helps you learn.
Stop Re-reading and Highlighting: Replace these passive, ineffective habits with active retrieval practices. If you re-read, do it with the specific purpose of answering questions you couldn't recall earlier.

Make It Stick is a guide to transforming how you learn by aligning your methods with how your brain actually works. In the authors' view, "We are poor judges of when we are learning well and when we’re not," and "learning is deeper and more durable when it’s effortful."

Crepi il lupo! 🐺