🎙️ TIP742: Invest like a Business Owner with David Fagan
A Framework for Ownership-Based Investing and Long-Term Value Creation
🎧 Listen here.
Investing like a business owner represents a fundamental shift in perspective that separates exceptional investors from the crowd. Rather than treating stocks as mere price movements or trading vehicles, this approach views investments through the lens of ownership: evaluating businesses as if you were buying the entire company. David Fagan, seasoned investor and business operator, shares his framework for developing this ownership mindset and applying it to build long-term wealth through patient, value-oriented investing.
The Ownership Mindset
The foundation of business owner investing begins with a fundamental psychological shift. As Fagan explains, "When you buy a stock you're not buying a piece of paper, you're buying a piece of a business. You become a part-owner of that enterprise, with all the rights and responsibilities that entails."
This ownership perspective transforms how investors evaluate opportunities. Instead of focusing on short-term price fluctuations, business owner investors concentrate on the underlying economics of the business, its competitive position, and its ability to generate cash flows over time. Fagan emphasizes that this approach requires patience and discipline: "The market is a voting machine in the short run, but a weighing machine in the long run. Business owners focus on the weight of value, not the votes of sentiment."
Understanding Business Fundamentals
Business owner investors prioritize deep understanding of the companies they own. Fagan outlines several critical elements that must be thoroughly analyzed before investing:
Business Model Economics: How does the company actually make money? What are the unit economics? What are the margins, and are they sustainable? "You wouldn't buy a local restaurant without understanding its costs, revenues, and profit margins," Fagan notes. "Why would you invest millions in a public company without that same level of understanding?"
Competitive Advantages: What protects the business from competition? These advantages are called moats and they can take forms like: brand strength, network effects, cost advantages, regulatory advantages, or switching costs. Fagan advises investors to "identify what makes this business special, and then determine whether that advantage is durable enough to withstand competitive threats over the next decade."
Capital Allocation: How does management use the company's profits? Do they reinvest wisely, return capital to shareholders, or make value-destroying acquisitions? "Capital allocation skill is perhaps the most underrated aspect of management quality," Fagan explains. "Great managers are like great farmers, they know when to plant (reinvest), when to harvest (return capital), and when to let fields lie fallow (hold cash)."
The Circle of Competence in Practice
Building on the concept popularized by Warren Buffett, Fagan emphasizes the importance of staying within your circle of competence when investing like a business owner. "The business owner approach requires deep knowledge, which is impossible to achieve across hundreds or thousands of companies," he states.
Fagan shares his personal approach to developing and maintaining his circle of competence:
- Industry Specialization: Focus on industries you understand through personal experience, education, or intensive study. "I started with consumer businesses because that's what I knew from my operating experience. Only later did I expand into other areas."
- Continuous Learning: Dedicate significant time to reading annual reports, industry publications, and competitive analyses. "You should know more about the companies you own than their own mid-level managers do."
- Honest Self-Assessment: Regularly evaluate whether you truly understand a business or are just following trends. "The market is very good at separating those who understand a business from those who merely think they do."
Management Evaluation: The Partnership Approach
Business owner investors view management as partners in their investment journey. Fagan emphasizes the importance of thorough management evaluation before investing:
Capital Allocation Track Record: Examine how management has deployed capital historically. Have they created or destroyed value? "Look at their acquisitions over the past decade. Did they pay reasonable prices? Did those acquisitions perform as expected? This tells you more than any management presentation."
Skin in the Game: Assess whether management has meaningful ownership stakes in the business. "Managers who are significant owners think like owners. Those who aren't may think like hired hands, there's a crucial difference."
Communication Quality: Evaluate whether management communicates honestly and clearly, even during difficult periods. "Great managers are transparent about problems and clear about their strategies. Poor managers hide behind jargon and obfuscation."
Alignment with Shareholders: Determine whether management's incentives align with long-term shareholders. "Stock options can be wonderful or terrible depending on how they're structured. Look for compensation that rewards long-term value creation, not short-term stock price movements."
Valuation from an Owner's Perspective
Business owner investors approach valuation differently from traditional investors. Rather than relying solely on metrics like P/E ratios or discounted cash flow models, Fagan recommends a more holistic approach:
Private Market Value: Consider what the business would be worth if it were private. "If you wouldn't buy the entire company at its current market cap, why would you buy a small piece of it?"
Replacement Cost: Calculate what it would cost to replicate the business from scratch. "If a company has a market cap of $500 million but would cost $2 billion to build, that suggests significant value that may not be captured by traditional valuation metrics."
Earnings Power Value: Focus on normalized earnings power rather than cyclical peaks or troughs. "Business owners understand that earnings fluctuate but true value lies in the long-term earnings capacity of the enterprise."
Margin of Safety: Always pay less than your conservative estimate of intrinsic value. "Even the best business can be a poor investment if you overpay. The margin of safety protects you from errors in judgment and unforeseen problems."
The Patient Capital Approach
Business owner investing requires a long time horizon. Fagan explains that this patience provides several advantages:
Compounding Benefits: "The greatest wealth is built through compounding over decades, not months. Business owners understand this instinctively: they don't expect to build a business in a year, and they don't expect their investments to compound instantly."
Reduced Transaction Costs: Long-term holding periods minimize taxes, commissions, and bid-ask spreads. "Every time you trade, you're giving up a piece of your return to the financial system. Business owners minimize this leakage."
Psychological Advantages: Long-term investors aren't tempted by market noise or short-term volatility. "When you own a business, you don't panic when the price fluctuates, you focus on the underlying operations. The same should be true for public market investors."
Alignment with Business Reality: Businesses take years to implement strategies and see results. "Quarterly earnings reports create an illusion of immediacy that doesn't reflect how businesses actually operate. Business owners look through this noise to focus on what really matters."
Active Ownership and Engagement
Unlike passive investors, business owners actively engage with their investments. Fagan outlines several ways investors can apply this principle:
Voting Proxies: "Many investors ignore their proxy votes, but business owners understand that corporate governance matters. Vote thoughtfully on issues that affect long-term value creation."
Direct Communication: When appropriate, communicate directly with management and boards. "You don't need to be an activist investor to ask thoughtful questions or provide constructive feedback."
Continuous Monitoring: Regularly assess whether your investment thesis remains intact. "Business owners don't set and forget. They continuously monitor their operations and make adjustments as needed."
Adding Value: Consider whether you can contribute to the business's success beyond capital. "In some cases, investors can provide industry expertise, customer relationships, or operational insights that enhance the value of their investments."
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Fagan highlights several mistakes that investors often make when attempting to apply the business owner approach:
Overpaying for Quality: "Even the best business can be a poor investment if you pay too much. Quality is important, but price is what you pay while value is what you get."
False Diversification: "Owning 50 businesses you don't understand isn't diversification, it's diworsification. True diversification comes from owning a manageable number of high-quality businesses within your circle of competence."
Short-Term Thinking: "Many investors claim to be long-term but panic during market downturns. Business owners understand that volatility is the price of admission for long-term returns."
Confirmation Bias: "Once you own a business, it's tempting to seek only positive information. Great business owners actively seek out negative information to test their thesis."
Activity Bias: "Business owners don't make changes for the sake of appearing busy. They understand that often the best action is inaction, patience and discipline are rewarded."
Implementing the Business Owner Framework
Fagan provides practical steps for investors looking to adopt this approach:
Start with What You Know: "Begin by analyzing businesses in industries you understand through personal experience or expertise. This provides a foundation for expanding your circle of competence."
Read Extensively: "Annual reports are the single most important resource for business owner investors. Read them cover to cover, including the footnotes. Then read competitors' reports, industry publications, and relevant trade journals."
Develop a Checklist: "Create a systematic process for evaluating investments. This should include both quantitative metrics and qualitative factors. Use this checklist consistently for every potential investment."
Maintain a Journal: "Document your investment decisions, including your thesis, the price paid, and the reasoning. Review this regularly to learn from both successes and mistakes."
Find a Community: "Surround yourself with like-minded investors who share your ownership approach. This provides perspective, accountability, and opportunities for learning."
Conclusion: The Path to Ownership-Based Investing
Investing like a business owner represents a philosophy that aligns investor behavior with the fundamental nature of business ownership. As Fagan concludes, "The greatest investors in history have all approached investing with an owner's mindset. They understand that stocks represent fractional ownership of real businesses, and they evaluate opportunities accordingly."
This approach requires significant work, continuous learning, and emotional discipline. However, as Fagan emphasizes, the rewards extend beyond financial returns: "When you invest like a business owner, you develop a deeper understanding of how businesses work, how value is created, and how capitalism functions. This knowledge is valuable regardless of market conditions."
By adopting the business owner framework, investors can transform their approach from speculation to ownership, from trading to investing, and from short-term thinking to long-term wealth creation. As Fagan reminds us, "The stock market is a tool for transferring wealth from the impatient to the patient, from the active to the thoughtful, and from the trader to the owner. Choose which side you want to be on."
Crepi il lupo! 🐺